Nick and Chip tailor their performances to their audience and welcome special requests.
| Title | Artist |
| A Pirate Looks at 40 | Jimmy Buffett |
| Alive | Pearl Jam |
| American Girl | Tom Petty |
| Angel of Harlem | U2 |
| As It Was | Harry Styles |
| Better Man | Pearl Jam |
| Blue Sky | Allman Brothers Band |
| Boat Drinks | Jimmy Buffett |
| California Stars | Wilco |
| Chain Gang | Pretenders |
| Comfortably Numb | Pink Floyd |
| Cracklin’ Rosie | Neil Diamond |
| Dead Flowers | Rolling Stones |
| Don’t Go Back to Rockville | REM |
| Don’t Think Twice It’s Alright | Bob Dylan |
| Folsom Prison Blues | Johnny Cash |
| For What it’s Worth | Buffalo Springfield |
| Free Bird | Lynyrd Skynyrd |
| Friend of the Devil | Grateful Dead |
| Friends in Low Places | Garth Brooks |
| Gambler | Kenny Rogers |
| Graceland | Paul Simon |
| Happy Together | The Turtles |
| Harvest Moon | Neil Young |
| Heart of Gold | Neil Young |
| Here Comes the Sun | The Beatles |
| Here There and Everywhere | The Beatles |
| Heroes | David Bowie |
| Homeward Bound | Simon and Garfunkel |
| Horse With No Name | America |
| Hurts So Good | John Mellencamp |
| I Can See Clearly Now | Johnny Nash |
| I Want You | Bob Dylan |
| In My Life | The Beatles |
| Into the Mystic | Van Morrison |
| Jokerman | Bob Dylan |
| Kodachrome | Paul Simon |
| Let it Bleed | Rolling Stones |
| Lodi | Creedence Clearwater Revival |
| Man on the Moon | REM |
| Man Who Sold the World | David Bowie |
| Margaritaville | Jimmy Buffett |
| Mary Jane’s Last Dance | Tom Petty |
| Melt With You | Modern English |
| Mrs. Robinson | Simon and Garfunkel |
| My Sweet Lord | George Harrison |
| Octopus’s Garden | The Beatles |
| Old Man | Neil Young |
| On the Road Again | Willie Nelson |
| One | U2 |
| Ooh La La | Faces |
| Peaceful Easy Feeling | Eagles |
| Piano Man | Billy Joel |
| Proud Mary | Creedence Clearwater Revival |
| Ramblin’ Man | Allman Brothers Band |
| Ripple | Grateful Dead |
| Rocket Man | Elton John |
| Rockin’ in Free World | Neil Young |
| Rocky Mountain High | John Denver |
| Shelter from the Storm | Bob Dylan |
| Sittin’ On the Dock of the Bay | Otis Redding |
| Squeeze Box | The Who |
| Sultans of Swing | Dire Straits |
| Summer Teeth | Wilco |
| Sweet Caroline | Neil Diamond |
| Sweet Home Alabama | Lynyrd Skynyrd |
| Tangerine | Led Zepellin |
| The Ballad of John & Yoko | The Beatles |
| The Boxer | Simon and Garfunkel |
| The Weight | The Band |
| There is a Light That Never Goes Out | The Smiths |
| Waiting in Vain | Bob Marley |
| Wild Night | Van Morrison |
| Wild World | Cat Stevens |
| Yellow Ledbetter | Pearl Jam |
| You Ain’t Goin Nowhere | Bob Dylan |
| You Don’t Know How it Feels | Tom Petty |
| You’ve Got to Hide Your Love Away | The Beatles |
| Ziggy Stardust | David Bowie |